- Client
- Company preparing to launch a new product
- Transaction
- Proposed acquisition of 30 patents declared as SEPs to ETSI
- Engagement
- Independent SEP essentiality assessment
- Outcome
- 8 non-essential · 6 essential but avoidable · 16 essential
Executive summary
Declared essential is not the same as essential
A client preparing to launch a new product was evaluating the acquisition of a portfolio of 30 patents that another company had declared to the European Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI) as Standard Essential Patents (SEPs).
Before committing, the client engaged IIPRD to assess independently whether each patent was actually essential to the applicable standards, and where licensing spend could be reduced without compromising product performance or quality.
IIPRD mapped every patent's claims against the relevant technical specifications and 3GPP records. The assessment found that 8 patents were non-essential, 6 were essential but potentially avoidable through alternative implementations, and 16 were essential and required further licensing consideration.
Background
How SEP declarations work, and why they need checking
Under ETSI's IPR Policy, members are expected to disclose patents they believe may be essential to a standard, and to state whether they are prepared to license them on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory (FRAND) terms. These declarations are made by the patent holder.
ETSI does not check whether a declared patent is actually essential. Declarations are often made early, before the specification is final, and may list whole patent families. As standards evolve, some declared patents end up covering features that were changed, dropped or made optional.
For a buyer or licensee, that means the declared list is a starting point. The real question is claim by claim: is it technically impossible to implement the standard without using what this claim covers?
Declared SEP
The patent holder has told ETSI the patent may be essential. Made unilaterally, without independent checking.
Technically essential
Every compliant implementation of the standard necessarily uses what the claim covers.
Commercially necessary
The client's product actually needs it. An essential patent on an optional or replaceable feature may not be.
ETSI defines "essential" on technical grounds: it is not possible to make or operate standard-compliant equipment without infringing the patent.
Problem statement
Thirty declarations, one acquisition decision
A client preparing to launch a new product was evaluating the acquisition of a portfolio of 30 patents declared Standard Essential Patents (SEPs) by a company to the European Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI).
Before proceeding with the acquisition, the client engaged IIPRD to independently assess the essentiality of the declared patents, determine their relevance to the applicable technical standards, and identify opportunities to reduce potential licensing expenditure without compromising product performance or quality.
The key objective was to distinguish genuinely essential patents from non-essential declarations and determine whether alternative technologies could provide technically viable workarounds for certain patents.
Engagement objectives
- Assess the technical essentiality of each of the 30 declared patents.
- Determine each patent's relevance to the applicable technical standards.
- Identify alternative technologies that could provide viable workarounds.
- Reduce potential licensing expenditure without compromising product performance or quality.
Key challenges
Separating declarations from essentiality
Validating SEP declarations
Determining whether each of the 30 declared patents covered technology that was genuinely required to implement the applicable standards.
Why it mattersPaying SEP prices for non-essential patents inflates the acquisition cost with no matching benefit.
Navigating complex technical specifications
Evaluating patent claims against relevant technical specifications, 3GPP documentation, and associated standardization records.
Why it mattersSpecifications run to thousands of pages across releases, and essentiality turns on precise wording in specific clauses.
Identifying viable alternatives
Assessing whether certain technologies covered by declared SEPs could be bypassed using alternative implementations without compromising product quality.
Why it mattersA patent can be essential to the standard as a whole yet avoidable for a particular product's chosen implementation.
Optimizing acquisition and licensing strategy
Establishing which patents warranted licensing and which could potentially be excluded from the acquisition or addressed through alternative technical approaches.
Why it mattersThe technical findings have to translate into a clear position on scope and price for the negotiation.
Solution approach
Comprehensive SEP essentiality assessment
Five stages took the portfolio from 30 declarations to a differentiated view of what the client actually needed.
-
1
Patent claim analysis & portfolio screening
Conducted a detailed review of all 30 declared SEP patents, examining their claims, technical scope, and relationship to the relevant standardized technologies.
What we examined
- Independent and key dependent claims of each patent
- The standardized technology each patent was declared against
Output
- A claim inventory for all 30 patents, linked to the relevant technology areas
-
2
Standards mapping & technical validation
Mapped the patent claims against applicable technical specifications, 3GPP documentation, and related standards-development materials to assess whether the claimed features were mandatory for implementing the relevant standards.
What we examined
- The specification clauses each claim element would read on
- Whether each feature is mandatory or optional in the standard
Output
- Claim-to-standard charts showing where each claim does and does not map
-
3
Review of standardization records & supporting evidence
Examined available internal communications, patent submissions, stakeholder contributions, and other relevant technical records to develop a deeper understanding of the standardized technologies and the technical context of the patent declarations.
What we examined
- Contributions and records from the standardization process
- The technical context in which each declaration was made
Output
- Background evidence supporting each essentiality finding
-
4
Identification of non-SEP patents
Identified patents whose claimed subject matter did not appear to be essential to implementing the relevant standards based on the technical evidence reviewed. These patents could therefore be challenged for inclusion in the proposed SEP acquisition or licensing package, subject to further legal and technical verification.
What we examined
- Claims with elements that have no counterpart in the specification
- Claims that read only on optional or alternative features
Output
- 8 patents flagged as non-essential, with the reasons for each
-
5
Alternative technology & workaround analysis
Evaluated alternative technical implementations for patents assessed as essential but potentially avoidable. The analysis identified lower-cost alternative technologies available from a competing technology provider that could potentially achieve the required functionality without compromising product quality.
What we examined
- Alternative ways to deliver the same functionality in the product
- Technology available from a competing provider, and its cost
Output
- 6 patents identified as potentially avoidable, with the alternative for each
Inside the assessment
What a claim-to-standard mapping records
Each declared patent is broken into claim elements and checked against the specification. The result for the patent depends on whether every element is required by the standard, and whether the client's product needs that part of the standard at all.
| Declared patent | Claim elements found in the specification | Feature status in the standard | Product needs it? | Finding |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Patent 1 | All elements, in mandatory clauses | Mandatory | Yes | Essential |
| Patent 2 | All elements, in an optional feature | Optional | Replaceable by an alternative | Essential, avoidable |
| Patent 3 | One element has no counterpart | n/a | n/a | Non-essential |
| Patent 4 | Elements match a superseded draft, not the final text | Changed before adoption | n/a | Non-essential |
Hypothetical rows that show the format only. They are not the client's patents or the specific reasons found in this engagement.
Breakthrough insight
The portfolio was not what the declarations suggested
The independent assessment revealed that the 30-patent portfolio was materially different from what the SEP declarations alone might suggest.
Non-essential
Assessed as non-essential to the relevant standards and therefore potential candidates for exclusion from the proposed acquisition or licensing package.
Essential, but avoidable
Assessed as essential, but potentially avoidable through technically viable alternative implementations, including alternatives available from a lower-cost competing technology provider.
Essential
Assessed as essential and requiring further licensing consideration for the client's intended product implementation.
This differentiated assessment enabled the client to move beyond the declared status of the patents and evaluate the portfolio based on technical essentiality, implementation choices, and commercial necessity.
Put simply, nearly half of the declared portfolio (14 of 30 patents) came with a technical argument for exclusion or avoidance.
Impact on client
What changed for the acquisition
- Improved acquisition decision-makingEstablished a more evidence-based understanding of the actual essentiality of the proposed 30-patent portfolio.
- Reduced potential licensing exposureIdentified 8 patents for potential exclusion and 6 patents for which alternative implementation strategies could be explored.
- Preserved product qualityIdentified potential technology alternatives that could enable the client to meet product requirements without compromising quality.
- Strengthened negotiation positionEquipped the client with a technical basis to question the inclusion and pricing of patents that were either non-essential or potentially avoidable.
- Focused licensing prioritiesHelped direct acquisition and licensing discussions toward the 16 patents assessed as essential and requiring further licensing consideration.
Policy & legal context
The rules around SEP acquisitions
Essentiality findings feed into a transaction that sits inside ETSI's IPR framework. These are the points that usually shape what happens next.
Declarations are self-made
Members disclose patents they believe may be essential. ETSI records the declarations but does not verify essentiality.
Technical definition of essential
Essential means it is not possible on technical grounds to make or operate standard-compliant equipment without infringing the patent.
FRAND undertakings
Declared SEPs usually carry a commitment to license on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms.
Commitments follow the patent
When a declared patent is transferred, the FRAND undertaking is meant to bind the new owner. A buyer takes the commitments with the patents.
Release and version matter
Essentiality is assessed per claim, against a specific release and version of the specification. A patent essential to one release may not be to another.
Findings are a basis, not a ruling
Non-essentiality findings support negotiation and should be confirmed with further legal and technical review before they are relied on in a dispute.
Summary of the ETSI IPR Policy for context; consult the current policy text for exact wording. This is not legal advice.
Key takeaways
Lessons for SEP acquisitions and licensing
- An ETSI SEP declaration should not be treated as conclusive proof of technical essentiality.
- Detailed claim-to-standard mapping is critical to distinguishing genuinely essential patents from non-essential declarations.
- Essentiality and commercial necessity are distinct considerations: even where a patent is essential to a standard, an alternative implementation may be available.
- Reviewing technical specifications, 3GPP records, stakeholder submissions, and other relevant evidence can reveal material insights that are not apparent from patent declarations alone.
- Independent SEP due diligence can help companies make better-informed acquisition decisions, prioritize licensing requirements, and identify opportunities to reduce avoidable costs.
- Check each claim against the specific release the product implements; essentiality can change between releases.
- Pay close attention to optional features in the standard; patents that read only on them are prime candidates for avoidance.
Value delivered
An acquisition priced on substance, not declarations
By independently assessing 30 declared SEPs, IIPRD helped the client distinguish between patents assessed as non-essential, essential patents with potential technical workarounds, and patents requiring further licensing consideration.
The resulting analysis provided a stronger technical and commercial foundation for the client's proposed acquisition, helped identify potential licensing cost-saving opportunities, and enabled a more targeted approach to SEP acquisition and licensing negotiations.
Frequently asked questions
SEP declarations, essentiality and workarounds
What is an SEP declaration?
A statement by a patent holder to a standards body, such as ETSI, that it believes a patent may be essential to a standard, usually with an undertaking to license it on FRAND terms.
Does ETSI check whether declared patents are essential?
No. ETSI maintains a database of declarations but does not assess essentiality. That is left to the parties, and ultimately to courts.
What is the difference between essential and commercially necessary?
Essential is a technical test against the standard. Commercially necessary asks whether a specific product needs the patent. A patent can be essential to an optional feature that the product does not use or can implement in another way.
How is essentiality assessed?
Each claim is broken into elements and compared with the text of the relevant specification. If every compliant implementation must practise every element, the claim is essential to that version of the standard.
Can non-essential patents be removed from an SEP deal?
They can be challenged in negotiation. A documented non-essentiality analysis gives the buyer a technical basis to question their inclusion and their price.
If we use an alternative technology, do we still need a licence?
Not for the patents the alternative actually avoids, provided it does not practise their claims. The alternative itself may carry its own licensing terms, so it needs its own review.


